Gene E. Bloch said:
I find that choro's statement about recommendations is flawed.
If I have used a program that works well for me, I don't see why I have
to try another one before I can tell someone about it.
I see why he requests what he does. Yes, if you've used one utility and
found it good, you can enthuse about it - as can other single users of
other single prog.s. This doesn't, however, help anyone to decide
between multiple options: it could just be that you (or someone else)
are better at writing in praise of something, rather than that it is
actually better. By asking for direct comparisons, he gets (if anyone
replies!) comparisons between two or more such utilities described _by
the same person_. (OK, personal bias can still rear its head, but at
least he isn't having to compare different people's views. And if he's
lucky, he'll get two or more people who happen to have compared the same
two utilities.
Or to simplify the above unwieldy paragraph: yes, you can say utility A
is great; what you can't do is say it is better than utility B which you
haven't tried.
As for using the analogy, I have to admit that I can't think of what to
do with it (he said sheepishly).
(-:
--
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()AL-IS-Ch++(p)Ar@T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf
live your dash. ... On your tombstone, there's the date you're born and the
date you die - and in between there's a dash. - a friend quoted by Dustin
Hoffman in Radio Times, 5-11 January 2013