dvdshrink and dvddecrypter are both free, both work perfectly, and
both are no longer supported. Still, if you look around I'm sure
you'll find one or both, and then you're in business.
SetupDVDDecrypter_3.5.4.0.exe
dvdshrink32setup.zip
Indeed I known someone who does this all the time.
The two rippers of choice are DVD Decrypter and
the Slysoft product. DVD Decrypter is tried
first and if this fails then the other. Some few
DVDs cannot be ripped either because of some new
nefarious protection or some unknown damage to the
disk surface. This incorrigible fellow follows
the routine:
1/ He rents movies on "tight-ass" Tuesdays or some
similar off-peak time.
2/ Then inspects the disks and washes them, and if
necessary cleans the surface with "Mr Sheen" or
car cutting-polish.
3/ He rips the whole disk (not 'just the movie')
to the HDD in it's own folder. DVD Decrypter can
be so configured. He rips all the disks and
return them to the rent shop on time to allay any
suspicion.
4/ On the following day he burns the rips from the
HDD using Nero8 (or later versions), but burns the
'movie only' to save space on the platters. Such
ripped disks can then be copied by Windows and
other software because the protection has been
removed.
5/ This rogue actually uses printable platters
that can be printed with the titles and critiques
from sites such as...
http://us.imdb.com/
http://movies.nytimes.com/
6/ He has gone so far as to install software,
typically:
http://www.audiolabel.com
that has a very-good print-right-round-the-edges
capability on the DVD surface, with a print-to-DVD
printer!